“DS4EVR” – I knew someone who had that on his personalized license plate. And it does seem to be true. Novels, comic books, CD dramas…even when one revival after another has been short-lived, “Dark Shadows” has refused to die. To a younger generation, Tim Burton’s movie may seem brand-new, but as Burton himself keeps telling them, it’s just the latest spin on a franchise that dates back 45 years. Props to Burton and Johnny Depp: I’ve never seen the people involved in a remake speak so highly of their source material.
Which is what makes it so hard to look at the movie objectively. How do you shake off the urge to compare it to all the versions that have gone before? Maybe it’s good that most everyone who looks at this blog is already at least somewhat aware of that history; it saves me the trouble of worrying about that!
To try to judge this movie on its own: Yes, it definitely works for me. It’s very funny at points, but at its heart it’s a serious story. The threats are real; people really die, often pointlessly. There is a deep sense of moral ambiguity – our “hero”, Barnabas Collins, is a vampire with violent urges he can’t control, yet he is also a man who loves his family and his home. The question is: Can the audience forgive the crimes that he hates himself for? Or are they meant to be unsure if they should? At least it’s refreshing to see a vampire movie without any of that absurd “vampires are cool” crap that typifies the modern fiction. No Anne Riceiness here; this is a vampire who loathes being “this hideous creature” and deeply, if helplessly, regrets the evils he has been compelled to commit. That alone would make this movie stand out today!
What makes it work as well as it does is that everyone else has a role to play. The Collins family may redefine “dysfunctional”, but there is still something appealing about them. Michelle Pfeiffer’s Elizabeth is clearly a little nuts, but her commitment to preserving her family is sincere. When she vows that they’ll endure, you not only know she means it, you’re in her corner. Chloe Moretz, as sulky teenager Carolyn, can steal a scene with one quiet, rudely accurate reaction. The little boy’s strangeness is blatantly a way of crying out for someone to listen. There’s a vulnerability that makes you care what happens to these oddballs, and makes it clear why Barnabas cares.
Will there be more to come? Yes, one way or another, there will. This year we have a monthly comic (with a just-announced spinoff miniseries), monthly CD releases, and a new novel for Halloween. There may well be a sequel movie, but if there isn’t, someone else will do a screen revival; this is, after all, already the third! Barnabas Collins will go on being a symbol of the conflict between good and evil within all of us, and a figure that anyone who is isolated, lonely or “different” can relate to. The Collins family will go on making us glad that our own families are no weirder than they are (or, maybe, letting us feel that someone else understands just how bizarre your family can be). And Collinsport will remain a place where mystery, magic, and even true love can be real. And maybe that’s something that we all need in our lives now and then. DS4EVR.
-
Recent Posts
Archives
Categories
Meta